I've been playing my bug-riddled, low quality PS4 version of Cyberpunk and all things considered I'm having fun. Mostly, I'm enjoying the writing, the atmosphere, and how some of the quest are structured - when they work. But yeah, very far from GOTY material. Personally, I'm still ok with this game because I tend to put a damper on my expectations.
A few things that come to mind - probably repeating some of the impressions mentioned here:
- The game heavily suffers from over-hype backlash. A lot of fans started to place unreasonable expectations on what this game should be like, and CDPR promoted the game as though it would satisfy all these expectations. It really reminded me what had happen with the release of Watchdogs 1.
- They must have decided to go ahead with the release because they didn't want to miss the Xmas window. But yeah, the game is clearly unfinished, and completely unoptimized for PS4. It looks like a 'PS3 game remastered for your PS4'. On the technical side, Watchdogs 1 is better than this, and that game was released ... 6 years ago. Ouch. Personally it reminded me of the release of FF XV, but while FFXV was incomplete at launch, at least it was rather bug-free.
- How many times did I hear "I don't need good graphics, just give me a good story!" for a rpg? Personally, I've always found this argument absurd, because it's often the quality of the visuals that contributes to your immersion in the world where the rpg takes place. This game is a very good example of it: I do feel like I'm missing out on a lot of the atmosphere of this game, because the graphics quality is lacking.
I'd still give the game a 8/10. But it's a far cry from 'the second coming of the rpg-messiah to rule them all' that a lot of folks seem to have expected.