Search results

  1. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 18 Spoiler Discussion

    Red XIII still acting as sagely and wise with everyone fully knowing he is a child nullifies the reveal at Cosmo Canyon, likewise all the character reveals with Cloud, the existence of Zack, his false status as SOLDIER, what happened with Sephiroth, have also been nullified. Wutai being a...
  2. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII Remake Open Spoiler Discussion Thread

    Yes, it's a whole thing
  3. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 18 Spoiler Discussion

    I'd certainly hope premonitions like Cloud had just looking at the Sector Seven pillar are a thing of the past but Aerith and Sephiroth actually forgetting what they knew a day before seems less likely.
  4. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 18 Spoiler Discussion

    Zack's death wasn't a sacrifice in the original, he just got shot. He did sacrifice himself in Crisis Core. It did not make him a virginal pure pink fairy princess. In my opinion anyway.
  5. Roger

    SPOILERS Avalanche cells and structure (open-spoilers discussion)

    Nevertheless, Shalue leaving hardly represents every sane person leaving AVALANCHE, and with the remake telling us that Barret's cell split of from AVALANCHE over a year ago, something far less then radical was calling itself AVALANCHE HQ loong before Fuhito stopped giving orders according to...
  6. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 18 Spoiler Discussion

    Cloud remembers killing Sephiroth, Sephiroth acknowledges the event and is cool with it. Aerith tells everyone Red XIII is a child, Hojo recognises Cloud and tells the crew that Cloud is no SOLDIER First Class. Is Aerith's narrative the only one too fragile to survive fundamental change to the...
  7. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 18 Spoiler Discussion

    I don't think she'll have a "Jesus-Death". But the heavy foreshadowing and meta winking in part of the experience we are getting. If Tifa's words about Aerith expecting to be coming back are gonna ring true then before Aerith leaves she needs to act like she will be right back, no need for long...
  8. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 18 Spoiler Discussion

    The whole Whispers thing aside, Wedge already talks to Aerith about feelings of being due for a reckoning as one doomed by canon character to another. I can't imagine these writers are gonna send of Aerith to the Forgotten City without a sense that she won't be coming back. Neither Aerith, nor...
  9. Roger

    SPOILERS Avalanche cells and structure (open-spoilers discussion)

    They didn't die 6 years ago, they outlived Zack.
  10. Roger

    SPOILERS Avalanche cells and structure (open-spoilers discussion)

    I think it'll be true in broadstrokes only, trying to assassinate the President is likely intended to be the most radical thing the group had done thus far. I can't believe the group that ostracised Barret for his intent to blow up Reactors had very nearly hijacked the Mako Canon and wiped...
  11. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 14 Spoiler Discussion

    Depending on the state Tifa finds Cloud in it's quite possible she has talked to him about it without getting too much in the way of reply.
  12. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 13 Spoiler Discussion

    You really have to clarify what initially means here, Cloud knows they've been looking into the Ancients for over 30 years, Elmyra knows Aerith was born into captivity and Iflana escaped when she was like 7. Even if they believe they'll return Aerith when they are done, they have no reason to...
  13. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 13 Spoiler Discussion

    Aerith was cornered in Sector Seven, she was buying her own survival as well as Marlene's with this deal. Hiring a bodyguard barely a day ago and risking being gunned down by Reno's goons to get away should still serve as a fairly obvious indicator that Aerith doesn't really like Shinra that...
  14. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 18 Spoiler Discussion

    Crono took that bullet for Cloud, thankfully.
  15. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 13 Spoiler Discussion

    Tifa quite specifically convinced Cloud to agree to condemn Aerith to whatever fate Shinra sees fit with the argument that maybe Elmyra is right about them letting Aerith go.
  16. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 18 Spoiler Discussion

    Seems like it went Jessie, Biggs and Wedge grew up together > Jessie left Midgar to become an actress > Jessie started studying planetology after her dad suffered Mako Poisoning > Wedge and Biggs live in slums where Tifa moved to as well > Jessie and Barret become part of AVALANCHE > Barret and...
  17. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 13 Spoiler Discussion

    Aerith hired Cloud as a bodyguard quite specifically to prevent Shinra from capturing her. Are Aerith's own wishes worth consideration on this matter? As for making things worse, Cloud (by way of Zack) knows about the Jenova Project, doing human experimentation to create the Ancient they needed...
  18. Roger

    SPOILERS Is this Compilation character being hinted at by *SPOILERS* throughout the game?

    He also personally met Angeal when him and Tseng got their asses kicked by him when they were trying to capture Hollander in Modeoheim. And had been fighting the Genesis clones for two years on various missions just like Zack.
  19. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 13 Spoiler Discussion

    In self defense, which I guess this wasn't. These guys were just going to hang around and look at flowers if Cloud and Aerith didn't start shit, I suppose.
  20. Roger

    SPOILERS FFVII:R Chapter 13 Spoiler Discussion

    Why? If her function is fulfilled, why leave her alive, if they still has use for her, why let her leave? And the answer to that question can't just make sense to Elmyra but also Tifa and Barret. And Cloud, who also was not sufficiently motivated to help Aerith anymore before the secret...
Top Bottom